Milton Township Annual Meeting: Residents Say Keep Township Government

Milton Township residents appear happy with the current structure of township government, after the April 10 annual meeting.

By voice votes, Milton Township voters at the April 10, 2012 annual township meeting affirmed the current structure of Milton Township government.  Two proposals for advisory referenda, one to cut the township budget by 20%, and another to eliminate the township altogether, were defeated by a large enough margin that proponents did not seek a recorded vote.  Thus, neither will appear on the November ballot.  Nearly 300 people attended the meeting, which filled the auditorium at the Wheaton Park District community center to standing room only capacity.

My unscientific observation is that many attendees at the meeting were residents of unincorporated areas of the Township, and they seem satisfied with the current operations of the Township and the services they receive.

My on the relative cost efficiency of township government versus other forms of government has provoked many comments.  Township government and its efficiency, or lack thereof, is under fire from a variety of quarters - the Better Government Association has made this a cause.  Interestingly, the BGA study uses "cost per mile" as an appropriate yardstick for highway operations - which some posters have criticized me for doing in my column.

But I believe the most important questions for any government body are whether it is responsive to those it serves, and whether it provides services in a cost effective manner.  I can't speak for every township in the state, or even in DuPage County.  But the answer for Milton Township is yes to both questions, and I think this is why the proposals were defeated. 

It's easy to complain about the number of units of local government that exist and propose arbitrarily eliminating some of them.  I could name a few.  But there are only two ways this helps taxpayers.  Either you eliminate the services the government body provides, or you find another government body (or private enterprise) to do them more efficiently.  From any of the township opponents, I have not seen specific figures to show that Milton Township operations could be turned over to the County, or somewhere else, and result in lower costs and better services.

Certainly there are economies of scale in government, like anything else.  Figures presented at the meeting relating to highway costs show a wide variation among DuPage County's nine townships, but Milton Township has the lowest cost per mile of the nine.  It also has the most miles of township roads; the townships with the fewest miles have the highest per mile costs.

But at some point, bigger government gets more bureaucratic and inefficient, and less responsive, as local control and accountability are lost.  DuPage County shares about 45 miles of boundaries with Cook County.  Yet we maintain a separate forest preserve, county board, court system, recorder, coroner, sheriff, jail, transportation department, et cetera.  Who's for dissolving DuPage County and annexing to Cook County, to end this duplication?  Didn't think so.

One area where government consolidations have occurred with some frequency is school districts.  But the Chicago Tribune looked at school district consolidations and found that, whatever other benefits might accrue, they did not save money; in fact, spending kept pace with state averages or went up.  Does this mean any consolidation is a bad idea?  No, but it has to be done on a case by case basis, and the financial benefits and operational efficiencies, if any, need to be clear.

One thing unique to township government is direct democracy - every year, any township resident can show up at the annual meeting, speak, and vote on township operations.  Thanks to all who attended, whatever your viewpoint.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Thomas April 11, 2012 at 06:16 PM
I think libraries should be the first to be consolidated.
John Mihas April 11, 2012 at 08:06 PM
When you pack the room with family and friends how can you lose.
John Sindalindin April 12, 2012 at 05:26 AM
1) Township residents did not say keep township government nor affirm the current structure; rather, what I suspect is that a majority of attendees were township committeemen and women who voted to prevent an advisory referendum from being placed on the November ballot for all residents to vote their opinion. Read - save my position and "prestige". 2) This was not standing room only, but rather not enough chairs out at the beginning of the meeting. Once chairs were placed those who wished to sit had plenty of opportunity.
John Sindalindin April 12, 2012 at 05:42 AM
A note on road maintenance: regardless of what number the BGA may use as their yardstick, they are by no means the expert on road maintenance. How about traffic studies that detail how the roads are used and the complexity of the system, and then relate that to how much it costs to maintain? Per square foot I am sure a grocery warehouse spends less on maintenance than a Ford plant - maintaining busier roads with heavier traffic is more costly than light traffic residential. Some creative critical thinking will go a long way towards improving efficiency at all levels of government, but Illinois Republicans and Democrats alike prefer to defend their status quo and protect their turf. In reality Illinois has single party government - "Demlicans" who all look alike. p.s. Enjoy the high taxes...and declining road conditions (no wonder they cost so "little" to maintain).
JR September 18, 2012 at 09:28 PM
Annexing DuPage to Cook is not the same as eliminating the Township. That would be more like giving Milton to Wayne township (i.e., just making the township bigger). Your school district analysis faces the same problem. Better empirics would be comparing DuPage's extra level of the Township to other areas of the country that do not have townships but consolidate with the county.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »